Panel Discussions - Tuesday, November 16, 2010
Famous Kant Essay on Peace Gets a New Read
What would it take to achieve a lasting international peace?
Immanuel Kant asked this question over 200 years ago in his essay “Perpetual Peace: A Philosophical Sketch,” where he effectively anticipated multilateral institutions like the United Nations and the European Union.
On November 16th, experts on peace including Robert Jervis, Adlai E. Stevenson Professor of International Affairs at Columbia University (pictured at left), joined practitioners from several multilateral institutions for an IPI workshop to discuss the relevance of Kant’s famous essay, which at its heart says that war between nations is natural, and peace can only be brought about by securing the rights of all through a federation of free states.
Austria’s Minister of Defense and Sports, Norbert Darabos, gave the keynote address, and a brief presentation on the significance of Kant’s text was given by Michael Doyle, Harold Brown Professor of US Foreign and Security Policy at Columbia. See full agenda.
The wide-ranging discussions began with a traditional definition of international peace as a relationship between states, but then quickly moved on to address the contemporary challenges of intrastate conflicts, transnational threats, and human security.
In the spirit of cross-disciplinary dialogue, each roundtable featured comments by a scholar and a practitioner. Then the floor was opened to discussion by all participants.
The day was organized around three roundtable discussions: “Sovereignty and Collective Security;” “Democracy, Governance, and the Rule of Law;” and “Human Rights and Cosmopolitan Citizenship.”
The workshop also presented selections from an original film produced by the Slought Foundation and the Perpetual Peace Project, featuring conversations with renowned philosophers and practitioners reflecting on Perpetual Peace with reference to current international priorities and conflicts. The event, “Sovereignty, Democracy, Human Rights: Dialogues on Perpetual Peace,” was held in cooperation with the European Union Institutes of Culture, the Slought Foundation, Syracuse University, and United Nations University.
To listen to the sessions, click one of play buttons below:
Welcome and Introduction (45min)
Session 1: Sovereignty and Collective Security (1hr 30min)
What is the current condition and future potential of global collective security? What reasonable constraints on sovereignty must states accept to exit their natural state of conflict in favor of establishing a global legal order with the goal of preventing war forever? Nonstate actors also have a growing influence on global collective security. How should sovereign states engage with them?
Session 2: Governance and the Rule of Law (1hr 22min)
To what extent is collective security dependent upon the spread of democracy and the rule of law? What is the proper role of the international community in promoting good governance and the rule of law or in strengthening weak and fragile states? How should “illiberal” regimes be addressed by the international community? Are they necessarily an impediment to the establishment of lasting peace and security?
Session 3: Human Rights and Cosmopolitan Citizenship (1hr 55min)
In a time of heightened population movements, what obligations does a right to hospitality create for the care and protection of refugees and immigrants? Who must satisfy these obligations? Currently, to what extent do human rights and international humanitarian law establish a layer of cosmopolitan or global citizenship above and beyond—or in complement to—national citizenship?
One of the pillars of IPI is its convening role. Each year IPI organizes a wide-ranging selection of meetings designed to facilitate strategic thinking and policy development on issues related to peace and security. IPI aims to strengthen public awareness through the generation of policy recommendations and the dissemination of research findings not only within the UN community, but within academic, political, civil society circles and beyond. This is achieved through a range of off- and on-the-record discussions, including policy fora focusing on expert briefings, examinations of military and police practices and preparations, book launches, speaker presentations, workshops and seminars, and full-day and multi-day conferences.
The Global Observatory
Can Hong Kong’s Protesters Win Over an Ambivalent Public?
Survey polls show that the attitude of Hong Kong’s population toward the ongoing protests is complex and multifaceted.
Key Global Events to Watch in November
A list of key upcoming meetings and events with implications for global affairs.
2014 Top 10 Issues to Watch in Peace & Security: The Global Arena
A list of ten key issues to watch that are likely to impact international peace and security in 2014, compiled by IPI's Francesco Mancini.
The Global Observatory, produced by IPI, provides timely analysis on peace and security issues, interviews with leading policymakers, interactive maps, and more.