IPI HomeEventsPanel DiscussionsPanelists Say Justice Necessary to Build Lasting Peace

 

print print  |  share share back back

Panel Discussions - Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Panelists Say Justice Necessary to Build Lasting Peace

“Peaceful societies are not built on the shoulders of war criminals,” David Tolbert, President of the International Center for Transitional Justice, told an IPI policy forum entitled "International Justice in a Time of Transition" on March 28, 2012. Mr. Tolbert was speaking to the recurring debate of peace versus justice, saying, “There has to be some reckoning for these crimes, and they have to be addressed. There are a number of mechanisms, including criminal justice, but also reparations, truth-telling processes such as truth and reconciliation commissions, and also, very importantly, institutional reforms.”

Mr. Tolbert spoke on a panel that included Peter Tomka, President of the International Court of Justice (ICJ), and Willem J.M. Van Genugten, Dean of the Hague Institute for Global Justice. The panel was part of the Peace and Justice Tour of the United States of the international courts and tribunals in The Hague in the Netherlands. Also present was Jozias J. Van Aartsen, Mayor of The Hague, who provided welcoming remarks.

Speaking about the transformative effect of the Rome Statute and the International Criminal Court (ICC), Mr. Tolbert said, “We see a new architecture develop. We see the end of the ad-hoc tribunals on the horizon.” He said, “The ICC prosecutor is a new actor on the stage. Essentially, with the adoption of the Rome Statute, amnesties for serious crimes—at least for those negotiators tied to the UN and other international bodies—is off the table. The creation of the Rome Statute and the introduction of the ICC prosecutor changes the dynamics very deeply for negotiators.”

He emphasized, however, that “The Rome Statute system puts the primary responsibility on states for investigation and prosecution of serious crimes and the International Criminal Court, essentially, as a court of last resort.” He said, “If we are going to actually see criminal accountability, criminal justice in practice, it is going to be at the national level. And this is a huge challenge.”

Mr. Tomka said that while the ICC focuses on criminal justice and individuals, the ICJ seeks justice in relations between states. It judges the disputes and responsibilities of states under international law, treaties, and customs. This allows the two systems—the ICJ and criminal tribunals—to work as complements to each others’ work. In its sixty-six years of operation, he said that the ICJ has “firmly established itself as principal judicial United Nations organization.” Together, he said, “The Hague-based international bodies are doing their best to promote justice on an international level.”

Dean Van Genugten spoke about transitional justice, defining global justice as essentially “about living a life of human dignity.” He said that a lack of justice can often lead to a breakdown of peace, citing the key demands of protestors in the Arab uprisings last year.

He also said that peace talks are disproportionately conducted by men, while women disproportionately suffer from the violence of the conflict. These women, along with a thorough understanding of the history of a conflict, are necessary to build lasting peace. “If you do not do justice to the real victims, you will never build up real solutions…it is about rebuilding trust, trust, trust again. The willingness to start talking instead of using muscles in a new conflict,” he said.

Mr. Tolbert concluded that, “Does international justice, does international criminal justice, restore citizens’ trust in state institutions? This is really the ultimate question for transitional justice institutions and transitional justice.”

Watch event:

The Global Observatory

Does Xi Jinping's Visit to India Signal a Shift in Sino-Indian Relations? Q&A with Hardeep Singh Puri
With Chinese President Jinping's first visit to India underway, the former Indian Permanent Representative to the UN discusses the future of Sino-Indian relations.

Key Global Events to Watch in September
A list of key upcoming meetings and events with implications for global affairs.

2014 Top 10 Issues to Watch in Peace & Security: The Global Arena
A list of ten key issues to watch that are likely to impact international peace and security in 2014, compiled by IPI's Francesco Mancini.

The Global Observatory, produced by IPI, provides timely analysis on peace and security issues, interviews with leading policymakers, interactive maps, and more.

Recent Events

September 10, 2014
Lessons from the Past, Visions for the Future: The Middle East After 1914
On September 10-11, 2014, the International Peace Institute launched its inaugural meeting at its Middle East Regional Office in Manama, Bahrain titled “Lessons from the Past, Visions for the Future: The Middle East After 1914.”

September 09, 2014
Threats and Opportunities for Energy Sector in West Africa
West African development depends on energy, and that energy depends on stability—this was one of the sentiments repeated during a September 9th expert roundtable held in Paris on the theme of energy and security in West Africa.

September 09, 2014
Preventing Mass Atrocities: Why We Fail, and What Can be Done About It
In the twenty years since the Rwandan genocide, the United Nations system has developed a considerable body of policies, principles, and practices dedicated to the goal of preventing future atrocities.

View More