IPI HomeEventsPanel DiscussionsBook Launch: Genocide and the Politics of International Action

 

print print  |  share share back back

Panel Discussions - Friday, October 25, 2013

Book Launch: Genocide and the Politics of International Action

The International Peace Institute launched its latest book, Responding to Genocide: The Politics of International Action, featuring a panel discussion with the editors and others on October 25.

Co-editor Adam Lupel, IPI Editor and Senior Fellow, clarified one aspect of the title early in the event. "When we speak about response, it should be understood that military intervention is one tool among many,” he said. “And that international actors can and should respond to the risks of genocide and mass atrocities long before violence ever takes place."

Gillian Kitley, Senior Officer at the United Nations Office on Genocide Prevention and the Responsibility to Protect, contended that there are ample opportunities to foresee and mediate these events before they happen. "History has shown that atrocity crimes are processes and not singular events,” she said. “They don't happen overnight."

The other co-editor, Ernesto Verdeja, Assistant Professor at the Kroc Institute for International Peace Studies at the University of Notre Dame, spoke about the importance of discrepancies in the definitions of genocide used by courts and international tribunals, advocacy groups, policymakers, and academics.

He said that legal courses of action in response to genocide can be blocked by clashes over what constitutes an ethnic group, as happened with the Tutsi population in Rwanda. Responses can also be bogged down by questions about the intentions of the perpetrators of atrocities.

“’Is that genocide or a really degenerate form of counterinsurgency?’” Dr. Verdeja asked, offering an example of the kind of semantics debate that slows action. “As if these things were exclusive from one another?” he added. These kinds of definitional arguments complicate policymaking, research, and the development of systems of prevention, the panel agreed.

Dr. Verdeja said that although most conflicts in recent years tend to be civil wars and don’t occasion genocide, there are correlations between the causes of genocide and civil war. He said both forms of violence tend to stem from a history of political instability, conflict, and marginalization of groups.

The book’s findings, he noted, also pointed to factors that differentiate the two types of crises. He said the risk of civil war is high in very poor countries with “mixed authoritarian regimes” where similar-sized groups can compete for some amount of political mobility. Genocide, however, arises in fully authoritarian, mid-level-income nations with distinct majority and minority populations.

"Civil wars make genocide much more likely, but of course, not vice versa," said Dr. Verdeja.

However, the panel agreed that whether it’s deemed genocide or counterinsurgency or civil war, it affects not only those in need of protection but people all over the globe in various ways. Crises create regional insecurity and mass flows of refugees, as well as put into question the ability of the UN Security Council, which is tasked by law with maintaining international peace and security.

Dr. Lupel said that a lack of political will is the biggest obstacle to apt, effective responses to genocide, citing examples in Rwanda, Bosnia, Darfur, and, most recently, in Syria. "Even if we know what needs to be done,” he said, “so often we lack the political will to act in a timely way because of concerns about sovereignty, because of domestic political opposition, because of financial concerns, or other reasons."

Ms. Kitley argued that, “We're still least effective when states themselves are the perpetrators of atrocities, and are strong enough and with enough powerful friends to prevent international action—as we are seeing in the case of Syria.”

"National interest rather than moral imperative remains the dominant basis of state action in international affairs,” Dr. Lupel said. "Preventing atrocities should be seen as a vital national interest, common to all."

The event was moderated by Maureen Quinn, IPI Director of Programs.

Watch event:

The Global Observatory

Killing of al-Shabaab Leader Throws Future of Militant Group into Question
In the short term, the killing of Godane is likely to result in more violent attacks, but longer-term consequences are hard to predict.

Key Global Events to Watch in September
A list of key upcoming meetings and events with implications for global affairs.

2014 Top 10 Issues to Watch in Peace & Security: The Global Arena
A list of ten key issues to watch that are likely to impact international peace and security in 2014, compiled by IPI's Francesco Mancini.

The Global Observatory, produced by IPI, provides timely analysis on peace and security issues, interviews with leading policymakers, interactive maps, and more.

Recent Events

September 19, 2014
Madani: Extremist Group Actions “Cannot be Associated with Any Religion”
Iyad Madani, the Secretary-General of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC), reaffirmed at IPI the Muslim world’s commitment to religious tolerance and human rights and sought to distance Islam from the recent violent actions at the hands of extremist groups across Africa and the Middle East.

September 15, 2014
Despite Disaffection, Youth Still Engaged with Democracy
Young people around the world appear increasingly disaffected with politics and political institutions, particularly in countries where corruption is rampant and government accountability is lacking. Yet during a September 15th event commemorating the International Day of Democracy, a group of young political activists from three different continents spoke at IPI

September 10, 2014
Lessons from the Past, Visions for the Future: The Middle East After 1914
On September 10-11, 2014, the International Peace Institute launched its inaugural meeting at its Middle East Regional Office in Manama, Bahrain titled “Lessons from the Past, Visions for the Future: The Middle East After 1914.”

View More