IPI HomeEventsPanel DiscussionsRoth: In Syria Peace Talks, Keep Justice—Not Impunity—on the Table


print print  |  share share back back

Panel Discussions - Friday, January 17, 2014

Roth: In Syria Peace Talks, Keep Justice—Not Impunity—on the Table

“There's always temptation for negotiators to jettison justice” in their haste to strike a deal, Kenneth Roth, Executive Director of Human Rights Watch, told an IPI forum on war crimes accountability in Syria. But, he stressed, "I think it's important for us to recognize that justice should be on the table at Geneva II; impunity should not be.”

The International Peace Institute cosponsored the January 17th event with the mission of Liechtenstein mere days before the Geneva II conference, a meeting of world leaders to discuss ending the Syrian civil war that has claimed over 100,000 lives and displaced millions.

Mr. Roth said both sides of the conflict have repeatedly committed war crimes. “The government has chosen not simply to shoot at combatants on the other side, but rather their probably primary war strategy is to indiscriminately fire upon urban populated areas that the opposition happens to hold with the aim of turning that population against the opposition…” he said. “This is 100 percent a strategy of war crimes."

Several panelists noted that segments of the opposition have been responsible for executions, systematic torture, and even massacres in some instances.

The ambassador of Liechtenstein, Christian Wenaweser, explained that even the parties in the conflict do not deny these atrocities—yet all refute guilt, blaming the other side. He added that a state of lawlessness can perpetuate the cycle of violence. “The lack of accountability, the firmly established culture of impunity in Syria, leads to the repetition of these crimes,” he said.

At the same time, a tribunal that holds perpetrators responsible can have the effect of helping to stop killing in the short term and heal cultural scars over the long run, the panel agreed.

The participants weighed several ways to address the crimes committed with an independent judiciary, such as a referral to the International Criminal Court (ICC) or a Syrian court, among others.

Jeffrey S. Howell, from the Syrian Accountability Project, discussed a hybrid tribunal model with elements from both within Syria and the broader Middle East region. He noted the contentious subject of whether this court should include the death penalty, which many parties on the ground consider non-negotiable.

The ICC, considered a standard for international justice by many, does not administer capital punishment.

There are two viable options to bring Syrian atrocity crimes to the attention of the ICC, according to the panel. One is a referral by the UN Security Council, though this would likely be blocked by Russia, one of the five permanent Council members, which has close ties to the Syrian government.

Craig Charney, president of Charney Research which recently conducted a survey in Syria, said that although he found broad consensus on a desire for accountability, Syrians remain “extremely resistant” to international actors imposing outside mechanisms of justice.

Despite complications, the panelists agreed, it’s imperative to begin any peace negotiation—such as Geneva II talks—with the understanding that amnesty must not be a bargaining chip, as it undermines prospects for long-term peace by continuing a disregard for rule of law.

Justice, however complex it is to realize in situations of civil war, has the opposite effect, according to Mr. Wenaweser. "Peace and justice are complimentary, mutually reinforcing,” he said. “It's extremely difficult to put this into practice, and I think Syria and the Geneva talks are a very stark illustration of that."

Ambassador Maureen Quinn moderated the event.

Listen to the Global Observatory interview with Craig Charney>>

Watch event:

The Global Observatory

The Search for Federal Solutions
The continuing spread of conflicts across the Middle East and Africa demonstrates the inadequacy of the centralized-state system and the growing appeal of federal solutions.

Key Global Events to Watch in August
A list of key upcoming meetings and events with implications for global affairs.

2014 Top 10 Issues to Watch in Peace & Security: The Global Arena
A list of ten key issues to watch that are likely to impact international peace and security in 2014, compiled by IPI's Francesco Mancini.

The Global Observatory, produced by IPI, provides timely analysis on peace and security issues, interviews with leading policymakers, interactive maps, and more.

Recent Events

July 17, 2014
EU and UN Seek Ways to Improve Cooperation in Peacekeeping
The European Union is among the strongest supporters of UN peacekeeping missions around the globe, but the growing challenges faced by UN-led operations have raised the need for better EU-UN cooperation, both on the ground and at the planning level.

July 07, 2014
IPI Hosts African Junior Fellows
The sixth annual African Junior Professionals Fellowship Program at IPI brought ten African scholars to New York for a month-long familiarization with the United Nations and the related think tank community, from July 7-31 2014.

July 01, 2014
SRSG Johnson: South Sudan Crisis Changed UNMISS “Mindset”
Hilde Johnson, the outgoing Head of the UN Mission in the Republic of South Sudan (UNMISS), gave an overflow IPI audience a dramatic account of the challenging situation that has faced the United Nations in the country since the eruption of mass violence at the end of last year.

View More