IPI HomeEventsPanel DiscussionsMalone: In Development, UN Is “Idea Incubator”

 

print print  |  share share back back

Panel Discussions - Friday, April 04, 2014

Malone: In Development, UN Is “Idea Incubator”

With the timeline for the Millennium Development Goals ticking down, the United Nations says its machinery is cranking at full speed to facilitate and produce the framework for a post-2015 development agenda before the General Assembly session in September. Whether that’s true or not, fortunately, the UN is an apt and important “idea incubator” for international development, contended Dr. David Malone, Rector of the United Nations University (UNU), on April 4th. Dr. Malone joined a panel of experts to discuss International Development: Ideas, Experience, and Prospects, a compendium he co-edited. The event was cosponsored by UNU and the International Peace Institute.

By examining how development evolved—how the “feedback loop” between theorists and practitioners shaped (or failed to shape) development—the book sets out to “slice and dice development ideas since the Second World War,” he said. “It's interesting to note that many ideas people aren't particularly moved by the failure of the ideas to work in practice, and similarly, many people who work on the ground were unaware that they were actually working to a set of ideas that has developed over a long period of time," he added.

The UN played a fundamental role in broadening the scope of development beyond mere financial gains to encompass social equity and gender equality, said José Antonio Ocampo, a Columbia University professor and former UN Under-Secretary General for Economic and Social Affairs.

In regards to implementation, the UN has employed a “miserablist” approach, said Dr. Malone. “Unless development's a total disaster, it's not clear the UN is required to do anything,” he explained. This leads to a lack of recognition of positive changes in the developing world, he added, of which there’s been plenty over the last twenty years.

He said that the MDGs and, until recently, the development community in general, focused on metrics—the number of vaccinations, child mortality rates, etc.—but that today people are increasingly worried about quality. “It's fine to have kids in school, but what are they actually learning?” he said. “Is it useful in the world today and so on."

There are many new challenges that development-agenda people have never dealt with before, said Amina Mohammed, Special Advisor of the Secretary-General on Post-2015 Development Planning. For example, of the UN’s three pillars—security, human rights and development—the former two are “leaning on the development one,” she argued. “We’re being asked to hold them up and deal with the challenges, and I'm not sure we're not going to collapse under it,” she added.

Middle class expectations and income disparities are growing global issues, noted Dr. Malone. "The importance of addressing inequality is growing in all societies," he said. Selfishness leads people to forget the plight of the poor as soon as they graduate from it, he contended. This lack of solidarity among the new middle class and poor is "extremely striking and potentially very destabilizing for the future," he said.

Climate change is another growing challenge the development community faces, said Ms. Mohammed, creating tensions between middle-income countries and others over who is most responsible to address it. Because these tensions dominate climate change discussions, she added, the development community misses opportunities for much needed dialogue on innovative solutions.

Successful development has always been “internally generated, not externally induced,” said Dr. Malone in closing. "And so the idea that development assistance can make very good things happen within societies, I think, is delusional. It's societies themselves that make good things happen."

The event was moderated by Gert Rosenthal, Permanent Representative of Guatemala to the United Nations.

Watch event:

The Global Observatory

Year in Review: Top 10 Peace and Security Reads
The International Peace Institute and its Global Observatory offered research and analysis on a range of topics in peace and security in 2014.

Key Global Events to Watch in December
A list of key upcoming meetings and events with implications for global affairs.

2014 Top 10 Issues to Watch in Peace & Security: The Global Arena
A list of ten key issues to watch that are likely to impact international peace and security in 2014, compiled by IPI's Francesco Mancini.

The Global Observatory, produced by IPI, provides timely analysis on peace and security issues, interviews with leading policymakers, interactive maps, and more.

Recent Events

December 15, 2014
Fathi: Iran and the Struggle Between Hardliners and Reformers
Discussing her new book The Lonely War: One Woman’s Account of the Struggle for Modern Iran at IPI on December 15th, author Nazila Fathi said that 35 years after the revolution, Iran is divided between hardliners and a large moderate middle class, but admitted that it is still unclear which of the two sides will gain the upper hand.

December 12, 2014
Effective Governance Key to Africa’s Rise
Good governance is the key to Africa’s rise, but structural challenges are pulling the continent back, according to a new report launched at a December 12th IPI policy forum entitled “Effective Governance in Challenging Environments.”

December 09, 2014
Small States in a Multilateral World
Despite their size and limited resources, small states have an important and crucial role to play in the multilateral system and can leverage their power through cooperation.

View More