IPI HomeNewsGeneral AnnouncementsEqual Citizenship Not Guaranteed in Draft Constitutions For Tunisia and Egypt

 

print print |  share share back back

A woman votes in Tunis, October 2011. Credit: Ezequiel Scagnetti © European Union
A woman votes in Tunis, October 2011. Credit: Ezequiel Scagnetti © European Union

General Announcements - June 03, 2013

Equal Citizenship Not Guaranteed in Draft Constitutions For Tunisia and Egypt

As Tunisia prepares to vote on its constitution next month, two reports examining draft constitutions for Tunisia and Egypt found that language guaranteeing equal citizenship between men and women has not been included, though citizenship was not explicitly undermined on the basis of gender. The two reports were prepared by the Arab Forum for Citizenship in Transition (FACT), a regional initiative supported by the International Peace Institute.

The first report, Equal Citizenship in Tunisia: Constitutional Guarantees for Equality between Citizens, examined several Tunisian draft constitutions from political parties and civil society, and found treatment of the issue of equality between men and women varied widely; the report said that some drafts “did not allocate a single article to enunciate equality and non-discrimination between men and women.” Most drafts did not give much attention to universal rules concerning human rights.

The report's author Salwa Hamrouni argues that the issue of equality in the Tunisian constitution “can be resolved in a single article that enunciates the principle of non-discrimination between men and women in all rights and duties, whether it relates to civil and political rights or economic, social, and cultural rights or family rights. The constituent power can also reach the same conclusion by always referring to both ‘male’ and ‘female’ citizens simultaneously.”

The report presents recommendations for the National Constituent Assembly to ensure the inclusion of freedoms, rights, and equality of citizenship in the constitution. It underscores the importance of adopting the principle of non-discrimination between men and women in all rights and duties, from civil and political rights to family rights, and pushes for the constitution to provide mechanisms to ensure the commitment of constitutional laws and principles.

The second report, Women and Equal Citizenship: Analysis of the New Constitution of Egypt, examined the final draft of Egypt’s constitution and found that important rights regarding the status of women were muddled in vague text and written with a conservative vision for the society. Egypt’s constitution was signed into law last December.

“From the perspective of equal citizenship, the constitution does not reach a satisfactory level in any of the dimensions examined and fails to reflect the spirit of the revolution in which women and men participated on equal footing,” argues the author.

Though not explicitly undermining citizenship on the basis of gender, the study, authored by Mohamed Al Agati, executive director of the Arab Forum for Alternatives, found that the draft constitution lacks proper mechanisms for the protection of women’s rights, with no mechanisms to address discrimination based on sex or the creation of oversight agencies. The study finds the document falls short of affirming and enforcing full equality among citizens, and remains traditional in form and content. The report recommends using legal, political and social instruments to work towards guaranteeing these rights.

The report found the gaps were a possible result of the clear lack of female voices in its formation—the Constituent Assembly had very low representation and participation of women (6%).

The reports were prepared by IPI’s Arab Forum for Citizenship in Transition (FACT), which aims to be a regional exchange platform on the exercise of equal citizenship in Arab countries in transition, with particular focus on gender equality. Working together with local civil society organizations and government actors, FACT pursues its vision though public policy-oriented research, advocacy, convening, and training, at local and regional levels.

More about the reports:

Equal Citizenship in Tunisia: Constitutional Guarantees for Equality between Citizens
This study aims to present conceptions and recommendations for the drafters of Tunisia’s new constitution in order to consider equal citizenship and its implication for equal rights and responsibilities.
Download report in English
Download report in Arabic

Women and Equal Citizenship: Analysis of the New Constitution of Egypt
This study attempts to reassess the final draft of the Egyptian constitution with regards to the status of gender from an equal citizenship perspective. The study bases its assessment on a framework of criteria drawn from several sources.
Download report in English
Download report in Arabic

 
 

The Global Observatory

Can UN-led Talks Bring Together a Fractured Libya?
The success of the negotiations hinges on the UN's ability to bring all parties to the table.

Key Global Events to Watch in January
A list of key upcoming meetings and events with implications for global affairs.

2015: Ten Multilateral Events to Watch This Year
A list of ten events that are likely to impact international peace and security in 2015, compiled by IPI’s Francesco Mancini.

The Global Observatory, produced by IPI, provides timely analysis on peace and security issues, interviews with leading policymakers, interactive maps, and more.

Recent Events

January 20, 2015
Mongolian Foreign Policy Between ''Two Giants''
On January 20, Mongolia’s new Foreign Minister Purevsuren Lundeg visited the IPI Vienna office and gave an informal briefing on Mongolia’s contemporary foreign policy priorities and challenges.

January 20, 2015
Dutch FM Koenders: ''The Security Council Has to Change''
Speaking to an overflow IPI audience on January 20th, Dutch Foreign Minister Bert Koenders acknowledged how far the United Nations has come since its inception 70 years ago but said that the organization still “has a lot of growing up to do.”

December 15, 2014
Fathi: Iran and the Struggle Between Hardliners and Reformers
Discussing her new book The Lonely War: One Woman’s Account of the Struggle for Modern Iran at IPI on December 15th, author Nazila Fathi said that 35 years after the revolution, Iran is divided between hardliners and a large moderate middle class, but admitted that it is still unclear which of the two sides will gain the upper hand.

View More